Research Guidelines
Manuscript Evaluation
Reviewer’s Information
|
E-Mail:
|
drkimberlyzhu@wzu.edu.cn
|
|
Title:
|
Language Editor
|
|
First Name:
|
Kimberly
|
|
Last Name:
|
Kolletar-Zhu
|
|
Affiliation:
|
Wenzhou University
|
|
Country:
|
China
|
|
Specialization:
|
Education
|
|
Google Scholar Profile:
|
|
|
ResearchGate Profile:
|
|
|
ORCID ID:
|
0000-0002-5347-9575
|
Evaluation Report
Kindly enter comments per section of the manuscript (All comments should be detailed to provide adequate information for authors)
|
General comment
|
There are several unclear sentences, word choices, and several punctuation issues
throughout the paper.
|
|
Introduction
|
Needs more information regarding your research and what you set out to find. Too
many references and outdated references were used within the introduction.
|
|
Literature review
|
Too many references and outdated references were used. More updated literature
should be reviewed and possibly more current information included.
|
|
Methodology
|
The methodology has a good design and used previously proven research methods
|
|
Results
|
Data was able to find many constraints and have proven alternative methods of
research should be held in the future.
|
|
Discussion
|
Thorough discussion regarding this and future research needs.
|
|
Bibliography/References
|
Too many references and outdated references.
|
|
Others
|
No keywords are listed. Various grammar mistakes. Too many references and not
enough personal writing and/or actual research information.
|
|
Final Note
|
I think the research is meaningful and deserve more attention. I think there should be
more recent literature cited as well as alternative and updated teaching methods.
|
Please rate the following: (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = poor)
|
Originality
|
2
|
|
Contribution To The Field
|
2
|
|
Technical Quality
|
3
|
|
Clarity Of Presentation
|
3
|
|
Depth Of Research
|
3
|
Recommendations
Kindly mark with an X
|
Accept As Is
|
|
|
Requires Minor Corrections
|
|
|
Requires Moderate Revision
|
x
|
|
Requires Major Revision
|
|
|
Not Suitable for Further Processing
(Please be clear and specific)
|
Word Template for Journal of Educational Technology and Innovation
Author Namea* and A. N. Authorb
a)Department, University, City, Country; b)Department, University, City, Country
Provide full correspondence details here including e-mail for the *corresponding author
Provide short biographical notes on all contributors here if the journal requires them.
Repeat the title of your article here
Type or paste your abstract here as prescribed by the journal’s instructions for authors. Type or paste your abstract here as prescribed by the journal’s instructions for authors. Type or paste your abstract here as prescribed by the journal’s instructions for authors. Type or paste your abstract here.
Keywords: word; another word; lower case except names
Subject classification codes: include these here if the journal requires them
Heading 1: use this style for level one headings
Paragraph: use this for the first paragraph in a section, or to continue after an extract.
New paragraph: use this style when you need to begin a new paragraph.
Display quotations of over 40 words, or as needed.
- For bulleted lists
- For numbered lists
Displayed equation ( )
Heading 2: use this style for level two headings
Heading 3: use this style for level three headings
Heading 4: create the heading in italics. Run the text on after a punctuation mark.
Acknowledgements, avoiding identifying any of the authors prior to peer review
- This is a note. The style name is Footnotes, but it can also be applied to endnotes.
References: see the journal’s instructions for authors for details